I’ve had an existential crisis and the Polestar 4 was to blame

Detail shot of the glass-lass tailgate of a white Polestar 4

Fourth in the sequence of standalone Polestar models is – logically enough – the 4, but its convention-breaking window-less rear is causing me much teeth-grinding and hair-pulling as I endeavour to answer what should be a simple question: how many doors does it have?

Industry word is that in the coming years we’re likely to see more than a handful of newcomers which are sold sans rear windscreen, so it’s important to set a standard for determining the door count of such models early on.

Front three-quarter of a gold Polestar 4

Sure, it’ll be important to revisit the standard once it’s in place to ensure it remains fit for purpose, but nailing it as early as possible will help to minimise future confusion.

Hang on – there’s no rear window?

Nope. Where glass would ordinarily be, the painted metalwork continues roofwards where, instead of a solid top, the Polestar 4 has a glazed panel, which extends beyond the heads of those occupying the back seats.

It sounds claustrophobic, but I’ll reserve judgement on whether it feels it until I’ve had the chance to experience the 4’s rear bench first hand.

Even if Polestar has ensured that those in the back of the 4 don’t feel like they’re occupying a bunker, with other manufacturers reportedly set to follow this trend, each example will rightly have to be considered on its own merits.

Interior of the Polestar 4

Rearward visibility is handled by a high-definition camera, with the display screen occupying a space where a rear-view mirror would ordinarily be positioned. This in itself isn’t new technology, but so far it’s only been used to augment a conventional mirror/rear window arrangement.

Even before the Polestar 4’s reveal, automotive chatter on social media has raged for several years about mirrors being replaced by cameras and screens, with debate usually concentrating upon how quickly and easily a driver can interpret distance on a two-dimensional display compared with a three-dimensional reflection.

Okay, so what’s the door question about?

With four side doors, an elevated stance and an aggressively tapered roofline, I’m comfortable categorising the Polestar 4 as an SUV coupé. I’ll give you a moment to wipe the tea you’ve just spluttered off your screen…

Yes, I’m aware that some will regard that as doubly oxymoronic, but we’ll save that debate for another day, because more important here is the question about door numbers – specifically in relation to the one that accesses the boot.

For decades, UK terminology applied to car bodies has typically meant that if a window is part (or the whole) of the opening panel then it’s considered a door, and if it doesn’t it isn’t.

Side elevation of a gold Polestar 4

Applying that convention to cargo space access means if the opening panel is glazed, then it’s a door – a tailgate, specifically – but if not, then it’s a boot lid.

So, while on paper, by dint of it being glass-free, the Polestar 4 has a boot lid, making it a four-door car, that doesn’t sit well with me, hence my proposal for a door-count category purely for rear screen-less cars.

This is the kind of clarity that salves my soul – please continue

Just as the existing glass-presence check convention for doors is a relatively straightforward notion for industry folk and the general public alike, a rule for cars without rear windows needs to be as easy to grasp as possible.

To set the scene, imagine you are stood behind a car without a rear windscreen and have fully opened the boot:

  • If through the opening you can see into the car’s passenger space and can pass items directly into it, then you’ve opened a tailgate, meaning that if its design is otherwise conventional, it will have an odd number of doors.
  • If through the opening you can only see the back of the rear seats and can only pass items directly into the passenger space if they are designed to fold over, then you’ve opened a boot lid of a car with an even number of doors.

Ergo, the Polestar 4 is a five-door car.

Crisis averted. Time for another cuppa (Yorkshire Tea, natch).

Elevated rear three-quarter of a gold Polestar 4

Responses

  1. Paul Horrell avatar

    Now assume your second case – it’s a ‘boot lid’. But it’s in a single-motor rear-drive EV. And at the other end it has a frunk (to be anglicised as froot, but that’s another discussion). Now surely the rear lid is the bonnet because the source of propulsion is beneath it. And the front lid becomes the boot lid.

    Mine’s an espresso Keith ta.

    Like

    1. Keith WR Jones avatar

      Paul, here you’ve touched upon a long-standing gripe of mine. Just the one, mind.

      It’s an issue that significantly pre-dates either of us, of course, harking back to the first cars with bodywork featuring distinguishable sections for housing passengers, cargo and means of propulsion.

      Let’s take Renault’s 4CV as a typical example: boot at the front, ICE at the back, with space for people betwixt.

      Such is (British) English’s occasionally constraining rigidity, even contemporary reviews avoided using ‘boot lid’ and ‘bonnet’ for the wrong ends of the car, regardless of such terms being correct.

      Even qualifying them further as ‘front boot lid’ and ‘rear bonnet’ failed to catch on, leaving us with unsatisfactory and drab descriptors such ‘luggage lid’ and ‘engine cover’, among others.

      Still using that 4CV as an example, I happily embrace your suggestion, particularly if championing ‘froot lid’ was an option.

      However, for a BEV with a single motor at the back, I’d argue it really depends upon what’s there when the boot lid or tailgate is popped open. Solely the motor? Then, yes, it’s a [rear] bonnet, but if there’s luggage space above – as is highly likely going to be the case given electric motors’ compact dimensions – it’ll be back to whether one can reach into the cabin.

      Taking another Renault to illustrate, this time the most recent generation of Twingo, both ICE and BEV versions have their powerplants located beneath the [rear] boot floor. To access the boot, a glazed panel – the tailgate – is elevated, via which the passenger area can be reached – and presumably entered if one demonstrated the requisite flexibility and narrowness of trunk. That’s trunk as in…

      Anyway, now that I’ve bored myself rigid, let alone everyone else, I’ll make a restorative brew.

      Would you care for a narrow biscuit to dunk in your espresso?

      Like

Leave a reply to Keith WR Jones Cancel reply